Contact Us
Leadership

What To Look For When Recruiting Your Recruiter

Published on Jun 06, 2022
graphic image of recruiter
Stay Connected!

Recruiting is the process of finding and hiring the best and most qualified candidate for a job opening, in a timely and cost-effective manner. Successful recruiting is paramount to a business’s success. Teams must grow and evolve in tandem with the company. If you haven’t figured out how to seek out and entice new top talent to your firm, you’re likely feeling the pressure and frustration of that deficit. Making recruiting all the more complicated is the fact that it is a process. That’s right – the cat is out of the bag! RECRUITING IS A PROCESS. This process involves several critical steps and stages. Dropping the ball or blundering at one of the steps can mean wasted time, money, and effort. Basically, it’s important to get it right. That’s why many organizations choose to outsource their recruitment needs. This can be a rewarding experience if done the right way. In this blog, we’ll take a closer look at how to properly engage with a recruiting or staffing agency.

Interview the recruiter

I know you don’t want to be the one doing most of the recruiting, but, in this instance, it’s important for you to play an active role. The market for recruiters and recruiting companies is huge. The one problem you won’t face is a lack of options from which to choose. So, here’s how to approach the initial “recruiting your recruiter” phase:

1.) Do your research! Google is great, but when you’re looking for a recruiting company, you just need more. Ask trusted colleagues about recruiters they’ve used. Ask about their experience – good, bad, and ugly. Referrals matter, as you know, so seeking out recruiters who have had success for other plaintiff law firms should be at the top of your list.

2.) Interview them! That’s right. Put them through their paces. Consider questions about their process, experience, approach, success rates, and interview style. Don’t be shy here. This is their chance to demonstrate to you that they are the right fit to help you grow your business. Ask questions like:

  • Will the recruiter take the time to understand your business?
  • Do they know your market?
  • Do they have experience working within the legal industry?
  • Do they have specific knowledge about personal injury law firms?
  • Do they really understand the roles for which they are recruiting?
  • Can they provide a general description of what a paralegal or case manager does?
  • Can they describe what makes a great intake specialist?

3.) Tell them about YOU! There is no such thing as overcommunication when working with an agency. Most of the time, they don’t know you and your firm, so it is up to you to tell them. A “discovery” call or Zoom meeting is recommended to introduce you and your firm and provide them with critical information. Give them information like:

  • Your firm’s mission and vision statements
  • A description of your company culture
  • Details like how many employees you currently have on staff
  • Information about what type of new team member(s) you are you looking for

Bottom line: You cannot assume a recruiter will know these things. Take responsibility for your role in this phase. Make sure you communicate your expectations clearly. If you take the time and put in the work during this phase, you can and will experience the relief that a good recruiter can provide you and your team. But, they can only succeed if they’re given what they need and if they are the right fit for your business.

What comes next?

After you’ve selected your recruiter, we recommend that you continue to see the engagement as a relationship. You’re working together to expand your team and your brand. They’re handling a lot of the heavy lifting, ideally, and saving you and your team time and money, but it’s never a good idea to hire a recruiter and then completely remove yourself from the equation.

Let them know where you draw the line

If a staffing agency or a recruiter is vetting candidates for you, it is imperative you tell them your HARD nos and parameters before the vetting and interview process begins. This helps to avoid awkward communication with potential candidates after they have already gone through some of the vetting stage. Provide your recruiter with the answers to questions like:

  • Is there wiggle room on your minimum requirements?
  • What is your social media policy?
  • Is previous experience necessary or can your firm train anyone who is willing to do this job?
  • What are the typical working hours, and are they flexible?
  • Do you offer remote working options?
  • What benefits are offered?
  • What holidays are observed?
  • What is your dress code?

Communicating as much as you can to your recruiter will aid in them sending you a good fit in a timely manner. After all, scooping up a qualified candidate as quickly as possible is the name of the game!

Setting the right tone

Did you know your recruitment process is a candidate’s first impression of your firm? The agency you select may very well be the first voice a new candidate hears and be given the first opportunity to sell who you are as a law firm and why anyone would want to work for you. After you’ve engaged with a recruiter, it’s important to continue to convey to them who you are and how you want new candidates to be treated. Your mission and vision will go a long way in this endeavor, but you may also want to consider explaining or providing them with copies of things like:

  • Your code of conduct
  • Team member newsletters
  • Team member bios (if not on your website)
  • Average years of experience for each position at your law firm

It is also important to communicate to your recruiter at what point you or the hiring manager will want to be involved in an interview. Since the recruiting process is the candidate’s first impression of your firm, it is important the interview be done in a timely fashion. This will help the candidate feel valued from the start. When the recruiter or agency brings you a well-qualified candidate, it is important to get an interview scheduled within a week or two, if possible.

The job advertisement

When working with a staffing agency, the job description for the role that you are hiring for is vital. It is how the agency will create your firm’s job ad. Job ads that are creative and out-of-the-box tend to attract lots of interest. Include, along with the job description, anything you may feel important to include in the job ad. Unique attributes about your company could be compelling and attractive to top-talent. Consider things like great cultures, job perks, team events, and special benefits.

Most agencies will know where to place your firm’s ad. However, if there are particular sites you would like it placed on, it is important to voice those to your recruiter. We also recommend you ask to see the ad and review it prior to the agency posting it on various job boards.

Make your recruiting process personal

Get to know your recruiter. They will be the first impression of your firm. Make sure they understand your expectations regarding candidates and in return make sure you are available for questions they may have for you. When using an agency or recruiter, remember the team approach. This is a relationship! You are working together for the benefit of your firm.

Use your time wisely and set your recruiter up for success. Like a new team member, give them all the information they need to do their job well. This will save you time and money in the long run! Getting the process right is imperative and will ensure you are retaining top-talent within your law firm.

Related Articles

Protected: Unlocking New Horizons: Why Mastermind Groups Are Essential for Law Firm Growth
There is no excerpt because this is a protected post.
5 min read
Read Full Post
The Power of Being Coachable: A Game-Changer for 2025
In this week’s blog, Chief Relationship Officer Sarah Waggoner dives into what it really means to be coachable, sharing lessons from her son’s first year of tackle football and her own career.
6 min read
Read Full Post
Leadership Lessons from Parenting: Tailoring Your Approach for Individual Growth
This week’s blog is a chronicle of Sarah Waggoner’s unconventional career path. As Vista’s Director of Talent Acquisition, she’s learned this type of trajectory can mold a well-rounded and dynamic professional.
6 min read
Read Full Post
How Did I Get Here? My Path to Career Change
This week’s blog is a chronicle of Sarah Waggoner’s unconventional career path. As Vista’s Director of Talent Acquisition, she’s learned this type of trajectory can mold a well-rounded and dynamic professional.
10 min read
Read Full Post
© Vista Consulting Team | 
Privacy Policy
Follow us: